Life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 06 december 2017 youtube. Life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 08 november 2017 youtube. During the arbitration process, both of these reasons have since been debunked. Mar 19, 2018 the reasons given by the officials for the decision to end the life esidimeni contract were not cogent said justice dikgang moseneke on monday on the last day of the hearings. The award on 19 march 2018, the government was ordered to pay r 1,000,000 to each of the claimants in. In a ringing indictment of the life esidimeni marathon project, dcj moseneke stated that the terrible tale of death and torture constituted a very serious breach of the constitution and occurred as a result of an abuse of power by servants of the state. Of the known survivors, the state informs that the whereabouts of 44 mental health care users remain unknown. Thus decisions stands between health on the one hand and death on the other. Final arbitration award arbitration tribunal sitting. Plans for a gradual reduction of beds at life esidimeni 10% a year, leaving 1200 by 201920 with accompanying development of community based care sasop letter to department of health in june 2015. Premier david makhura, on monday 19 march 2018, welcomed the redress award for the life esidimeni victims that was announced by retired chief justice dikgang moseneke.
Former deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke during the life esidimeni arbitration hearing at emoyeni conference centre, parktown on october 10, 2017 in johannesburg, south africa. Mhc users, their families, csos, prof orgs tried to persuade govt to devise a plan to protect their rightsneeds prior to being moved out of life esidimeni. So thats just a starting point to which you then need to do some analysis. The gauteng government has paid out r159 460 000 to the claimants of the life esidimeni arbitration, it said on wednesday. Life esidimeni arbitration award free download as pdf file. This is the question the arbitration process for families of psychiatric patients who died in the life esidimeni saga, will seek to address. The life esidimeni arbitration and the actuarial quantification of constitutional damages by ga whittaker presented at the actuarial society of south africas 2018 convention 2425 october 2018, cape town international convention centre abstract in the instance of a claim for constitutional damages where an aggrieved party makes a claim. Life esidimeni arbitration award by retired deputy chief. Is that all lighting that is available here, this is dark. The life esidimeni arbitration hearings have resumed with more. Their agreement was memorialized in the private compromise settlement agreement csa and the public consent arbitration award. Pdf on jul 12, 2018, ames dhai and others published the life esidimeni tragedy arbitration award.
Jul 01, 2018 this editorial describes some aspects of the subsequent arbitration award. Psyssa statement on the the life esidimeni arbitration. The life esidimeni arbitration is the first time in south african history that constitutional damages have been sought for the violation of mental health care patients rights in a 100page arbitration ruling, former deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke, who presided over the arbitration proceedings, said the life esidimeni transfers breached several constitutional rights, particularly. The 43 days of evidence and two days of legal argument were broadcast live. A total of 144 mental healthcare patients died after their moves from the life esidimeni facilities, which began in october 2015. Decisions about and on health affect and impact on wellbeing, the quality of life and the preservation of life and consequently, life span. Premier makhura welcomes the life esidimeni redress award. The arbitration heard heartbreaking testimony from family members represented separately by section27, the legal aid clinic and solidarity about the state in which they found their loved ones.
The life esidimeni tragedy arbitration award african journals online. Considering the death toll is now believed to be over 140 and some patients still unaccounted for, these are indeed sad days in our country. Moseneke, delivered an elaborate and stinging arbitration award. The life healthcare esidimeni scandal involved the deaths of 143 people at psychiatric facilities in the gauteng province of south africa from causes including starvation and neglect. Retired chief justice dikgang moseneke is presiding over arbitration hearings for families who lost relatives when they were moved from life esidimeni homes into illegal and illequipped nongovernmental. The life esidimeni arbitration hearings into the deaths of 141 mentally ill patients resumes in parktown, johannesburg. Section27 welcomes the life esidimeni arbitration award. No funds, yet life esidimeni dispute resolution process to. The life esidimeni tragedy in south africa harvard university. And his death certificate simply states that it is.
Contribution of the health ombud to accountability. This was one of the findings of the final report on the health departments decision to terminate its contract with life esidimeni the psychiatric facility tasked with caring for the patients in licensed private homes the 94 deaths according to the health ombudsman professor malegapuru makgoba. When such decisions go wrong, wellbeing, quality of life and life span are all compromised. The arbitration award by deputy chief justice moseneke notes, it is now undisputed that as a result of the move, 144 mental healthcare users died and 1,408 were exposed to trauma and morbidity. It is named after life esidimeni, a subsidiary of life healthcare, the private healthcare provider from which patients were removed by the state. Oct 31, 2017 the life esidimeni arbitration hearings have exceeded expectations, allowing relatives to express their pain and accused individuals a chance to be crossexamined. The uk address of the former gauteng health mec proving difficult to find, delaying summons to testify in deaths of 141 patients. Psyssa statement on the the life esidimeni arbitration hearings. Final arbitration award arbitration tribunal sitting in the. Life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 06 december 2017 part 2 duration. The life esidimeni arbitration and the actuarial quantification of. Life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 06 december 2017.
With the rest of the nation, psyssa follows the life esidimeni arbitration hearings with great interest. During the arbitration process, it was reported that 1,418 patients who had suffered trauma and poor health but survived had been returned to life esidimeni facilities for continued care. This morning retired chief justice moseneke presented his final report on the alternative dispute resolution adr process which was concluded in february. Life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 08 november 2017. What a horrifying scandal reveals about the rotting of the state under jacob zuma. These differing numbers are symptomatic and pathognomonic of an institution with poor data. Life esidimeni arbitration award pdf free download. Life esidimeni arbitration award retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke made damning observations in his judgment on monday about the sheer lack of official accountability for the life esidimeni tragedy. Life esidimeni south african human rights commission. Arbitration award, by justice moseneke where he states the requirement of. This comes after retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke handed down an arbitration award of r160. Plans for a gradual reduction of beds at life esidimeni 10% a year, leaving 1200 by 201920 with accompanying development of community based care sasop letter to department of. In full life esidimeni arbitration handed down by moseneke. English translations of selected afrikaans judgments.
At the same time it is gratifying to know that the hearings are. Qedani mahlangu still mia in uk stalling subpoena to life. Dec 05, 2017 life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 8 december 2017 part 3 duration. Around 2000 people, who were receiving highlyspecialised chronic psychiatric care, were to be moved out of life. Life esidimeni arbitration hearings, 8 december 2017 part 3 duration. Life esidimeni arbitration 30th november 2017 day session 1 3. State informs that the whereabouts of 44 mental health care users remain unknown. This was one of the findings of the final report on the health departments decision to terminate its contract with life esidimeni the psychiatric facility tasked with caring for the patients in licensed private homes.
In october 2015, the mec for health in gauteng, qedani mahlangu, announced the termination of the contract between the department of health and life esidimeni. The gauteng directorate of mental health gdmh could only identify 48 deaths. Pdf contribution of the health ombud to accountability. Reverend joseph maboe visits the grave of his son, billy, a former life esidimeni patient. While the state conceded liability, the parties disputed. Justice, may i request the camera people to change the direction of the light so that it is not shining right in our faces. The life esidimeni arbitration hearings have exceeded expectations, allowing relatives to express their pain and accused individuals a chance to be crossexamined. Gauteng departments to pay r160m esidimeni arbitration award retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke ordered that 5 families be paid out by 19 june. The arbitration award by deputy chief justice moseneke notes, it is now undisputed that as a result of the move, 144 mental healthcare users died.
The daily vox spoke to some joburgers to find out what they hope the outcome of the arbitration will be. The decision to terminate the life esidimeni contract was irrational use of public power and in blatant breach of the law and constitution. Life esidimeni, a private health institution with multiple facilities in gauteng, had a relationship with the state dating back three decades to before the dawn of democracy providing it with services for mchus. The life esidimeni tragedy how 143 mentally ill south africans were sent to their deaths.
Mar 20, 2018 retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke made damning observations in his arbitration award on monday about the sheer lack of official accountability for the life esidimeni tragedy. November page 2 of 169 session 1 arbitrator justice moseneke. Retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke made damning observations in his judgment on monday about the sheer lack of official accountability for the life esidimeni tragedy. On 19th march 2018, the arbitration award was read out by justice dikgang moseneke. The life esidimeni arbitration award granted each claimant r1. Nov 08, 2017 the life esidimeni arbitration hearings into the deaths of 141 mentally ill patients resumes in parktown, johannesburg. How 143 mentally ill south africans were sent to their deaths. Mar 19, 2018 the award amount, however, far exceeds the r28 million that gauteng finance mec, barbara creecy, allocated to life esidimeni compensation costs in her budget vote speech in march. Retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke made damning observations in his arbitration award on monday about the sheer lack of official accountability for the life esidimeni tragedy. Johannesburg just a day after commemorating world mental health day, mental health will be in the spotlight as an alternative dispute resolution arbitration into the life esidimeni saga begins. A tearful ntombifuthi dladla walked out of the life esidimeni arbitration hearings as a witness testified that her brothers body was badly decomposed and smelling when it was delivered at the. Life esidimeni claimants receive r159m payout from gauteng. On june 2018, the department paid r159 460 000 in compensation to the 4 claimants who were part of the life esidimeni arbitration r1. Mar 20, 2018 the life esidimeni arbitration attracted significant public attention.
Relatives embrace section 27s advocate adila hassi after the ruling in the life esidimeni arbitration hearing was made. Lawyers hope to bring three key witnesses, including former gauteng health. Section27 is representing 66 families whose loved ones passed away as a result of the marathon project. Section27 welcomes the award handed down by retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke. Life esidimeni for the 143 deceased average per deceased normal 21. The life esidimeni arbitration attracted significant public attention. Constitutional court order nkabinde and another v jsc 16 may 2016. Sep 19, 2019 the arbitration award by deputy chief justice moseneke notes, it is now undisputed that as a result of the move, 144 mental healthcare users died and 1,408 were exposed to trauma and morbidity.
Grossly inadequate and uncoordinated government spending on treatment of mental illness which affects one in six south africans is costing south africa 2. Witness at life esidimeni hearing reduces family member to. The life esidimeni scenario presents a series of human rights violations embedded in. All financial claims have been settled in compliance with the award given by retired deputy chief justice dikgang moseneke following the alternative dispute resolution process entered into with the families affected by the life esidimeni tragedy. Linkpage citation past issues of the south african journal of bioethics and law have discussed the ethical violations and human rights abuses that were committed during the life esidimeni tragedy. The right to life is at the basis of all human rights. Esidimeni deaths no funds, yet life esidimeni dispute resolution process to go ahead. The reasons given by the officials for the decision to end the life esidimeni contract were not cogent said justice dikgang moseneke on monday on the last day of the hearings.
743 632 1256 1441 1067 1171 612 523 869 141 357 704 284 866 547 1183 363 1093 1103 241 702 1127 794 295 213 613 1465 828 1400 267 1177 789 1492 90 215 754 148 103 844